Why we stopped recommending Mailchimp.
For fifteen years it was the right answer. In 2026 it's the wrong default for almost every small business we work with — and we can show you the math.
Plain-English guides, no fluff
For about fifteen years, “use Mailchimp” was the right thing to tell a small business owner. It was free until you got real, easy enough that a non-technical person could actually use it, and it didn't try to sell you a “platform.”
In 2026, none of those things are still true. We pulled it off the Advisor's recommendation list six weeks ago, and we want to explain why — partly because the post is overdue, and partly because you might still be paying them money you shouldn't be.
The case for Mailchimp, briefly
Let's be fair. There's still a version of you that should keep using it. If you have a list of fewer than 500 people, you only send a newsletter once a month, and you have zero interest in automation, Mailchimp's free tier is genuinely fine. Don't switch for switching's sake.
If that's not you — and for almost every shop running a real customer list, it isn't — read on.
Where it stops working
The break happens around the moment you want to do anything personalized. A reactivation email when someone hasn't booked in 90 days. A "happy birthday" coupon. A different message to first-time customers vs. regulars. The kinds of things a CRM is supposed to do.
Mailchimp can technically do all of these. The catch: doing them lands you in their "Standard" or "Premium" tiers, which start at $20/mo and climb fast. And the automation builder — the part that actually does the personalization — has a learning curve steep enough that most non-marketers abandon it before getting anything live.
Open Mailchimp. Try to set up an automated email that goes out 30 days after a customer's last visit, but only if they spent more than $100, in their preferred service category. If you can do it in 60 seconds without Googling, ignore this article. If you can't — that's the gap we're talking about.
The real cost
Here's where it gets specific. The numbers below reflect the typical Mailchimp setup we see when we audit a small-business stack — average list size around 1,800 contacts on the Standard tier.
$58/month is $696/year. For a feature these owners are barely using — sending one or two campaigns a month with no automation — that's not a tool, it's a tax.
What we recommend instead
Two answers, depending on what you actually need.
If you mostly want to send a newsletter and forget about it: Buttondown or Beehiiv.
Buttondown is $9/month at the size most small shops are at, and the editor is a single text box. That's it. You write, you click send. Beehiiv is free up to 2,500 subscribers and includes a real growth engine if you want one. Either one will save you $40+/month and feel less like work.
If you want automation that actually works: Customer.io or Klaviyo.
This is the one most shops should be on. Both are real CRMs with real automation builders. Klaviyo is the e-comm default; Customer.io is the local-services default. Both start around $25/mo for the size you're at, and the automation lift versus Mailchimp is night-and-day. That's where the reactivation flows and birthday emails actually become reasonable to set up.
It's not that Mailchimp got worse. It's that the alternatives got dramatically better, and the price gap finally tipped the other way.
— WHAT WE KEEP SAYING ON ADVISOR CALLS
What changed in the last twelve months
Three things. They all matter.
One: Beehiiv crossed the chasm. A year ago it was a creator product. In Q4 2025 they shipped real automation, real segmentation, and a free tier that handles real list sizes. At small-business volumes, it holds up.
Two: Customer.io's pricing got sane for small shops. Their old plans started at $150/mo, which made sense for D2C brands and not for a dental practice. The new "starter" plan is $25 and covers what 90% of shops need.
Three: Mailchimp leaned harder into being a "marketing platform." That's polite-speak for "we'd like to charge you for things you didn't ask for." The pricing pages are now genuinely confusing, and "engaged contacts" math means your bill can creep up without you doing anything different.
How to actually switch
If you're going to do this, do it right. The most common failure mode is starting a migration, getting stuck halfway, and paying for two tools at the same time for months. Don't be that.
The whole thing — pulling your list, importing it, rebuilding two or three flows, and turning Mailchimp off — should take a long Tuesday afternoon. Not a project. Not a "Q3 initiative." A Tuesday.
If you're an Advisor customer, this is exactly the kind of thing the Advisor will walk you through end-to-end. Ask it: "I'm on Mailchimp, list of 1,800, what should I move to and how?" — and it'll write you the migration plan with timestamps.
One more thing
None of these tools pay us. We don't take affiliate money. That's worth saying again because it's the only reason an article like this is allowed to exist. The day we start collecting kickbacks is the day this whole Guide stops being useful, and we know it.
So: stop paying Mailchimp $58/month for a newsletter you send twice a quarter. Move to a tool that fits the size of your business and the actual job you're hiring it for. The math gets better immediately, and the work — the part that's supposed to feel hard — gets easier instead.
The Field Guide · No affiliate revenue from any tool we recommend. Ever.
Get the next guide
before everyone else.
One specific tactic, one good tool, one idea worth stealing — every week, in plain English.